Hi everyone! This may be a bit long. I'd rather add too much than too little, so I apologize in advance. I have a feeling people may be critical of me, which is understandable, but please try to be constructively critical. I'm just going to jump right into it!

At the end of my 7th grade year, I started dating G. G was an outstanding boyfriend. During the middle of my 9th grade year, I started feeling bored. This boredom also came with less patience, more frustration, less attraction, etc. I only focused on these negative feelings I was experiencing in our relationship, and with a combination of immaturity and inexperience, I made the decision to breakup with him. Admittedly, I started talking to someone else a few days before breaking up with him; the guy acted as his replacement as I haven't been able to be single since G and I began dating. As you can imagine, he was destroyed. We kept in touch for maybe a week per his request, but then broke it off. To be clear, he was never upset with me. He told me it was ok and he wasn't mad or upset with me. I do believe him because he's always been incredibly patient and understanding and I apologized multiple times to him over several months, and every time it was the same patient and understanding G.

A little over a month later, I started dating K and I broke up with K at the end of my 10th grade year. I broke up with K because he hadn't been fulfilling his role as a boyfriend for a few months and I was tired of giving him chances. I mulled over the decision to break up with K for multiple days, as I loved him but didn't appreciate how he was treating me. While I was trying to make a decision, I was thinking about G. I was thinking about how great of a boyfriend, and person, he was compared to K, how I missed him, etc. I was also thinking about the possibility of us getting back together. As I said, I haven't been able to be single since dating G, and considering I was remembering our relationship with rose colored glasses, I'm wondering if this was almost a defense mechanism for me. If he was on my back burner, so if I broke up with K I wouldn't be single and lonely. But, I do truly still have love for G and I believe I truly miss him sometimes. Anyways, I text G the day I broke up with K, before I broke up with K. I told G I missed him and asked if getting back together was a possibility. He said it was, but not currently. He said he wanted to work on himself. I asked him if he had an idea of when he'd be ready and he didn't know. He told me not to wait for him.

At the beginning of 11th grade, I started dating A. A and I are currently dating, we're a little over 9 months in. A has also been an outstanding boyfriend. But, G has been occupying my mind and that's why I'm here.

My mom mentioned G the other day and I was struck with this feeling of boredom with A the other day. I don't remember which came first or if it was a domino effect, like my mom mentioning G gave me this feeling of boredom with A, so I'm not sure which caused me to start thinking about G, but now I've been thinking about G. Like before, my thoughts are about how good our relationship was, and how I miss it and him. And, I just have all of these conflicting, confusing thoughts.

I don't think I'm having as many negative experiences with A that I was having with G, but I think it's because A and I have more in person oppurtunities than G and I did which is a good thing right? But, this makes me think that had I just had more in person oppurtunities with G, we could still be together.

I don't want to ruin my pretty good relationship with A and hurt him for no reason, but I don't want to miss an oppurtunity with G.

I don't want to put G through anything again and bring up all of that hurt by starting communication with him again, but like I said, we've communicated multiple times in the past and he was always patient and understanding and I trust that's how he truly is and feels. To be honest, I searched him up on Instagram, though he has no pictures posted of his own, he was tagged in a few photos. 1 was a group photo, girls and boys, and he was at the very edge of the picture, far away from the girls, which makes me believe what he said about working on himself is true, but it also makes me believe that if I asked to get back together now, I'd get that exact same answer.

The easiest thing to do would be to text G asking if he's ready, but I don't want to do that to A. It's basically cheating in my book, and I don't want to repeat that pattern again. Plus, when I did that in the past, whether I had the replacement or not, I still broke up with the guy because I had those pretty strong negative feelings, but I don't have those with A. So, if I message G and get a no, then I stay with A, making him a victim of my emotional cheating pattern and putting him in 2nd place compared to G, unbeknownst to him, and if G says yes, which I doubt would happen, I'd be destroying A by leaving him for someone else, which I don't want to repeat either.

Right now, I plan to just wait it out. I'll see if this boredom continues or if anything else happens to make us break up, and if it does then I'll talk to G.

If I've got this plan, why am I asking for help? Well, I just feel horrible about the situation. This is genuinely 1 of the last things I wanted to happen to my relationship with A. I figured this would happen, but I was hoping it wouldn't, or that we'd at least get to 1 year and 3 months like my other 2 relationships before this happened. I feel so guilty about feeling this way when A has been nothing but great to me and for me. But, there's just a thought in the back of my head and a pit in the bottom of my stomach that tells me that G is my person and by being with A I'm missing an oppurtunity with G, and if he starts dating someone I may never have the oppurtunity again. I just feel like I'm spiraling.

Honestly, I think this whole situation might be a topic for a therapist, but I don't have access to that.

So, I'm wondering if anyone has experienced this or knows someone who has, or has any words of wisdom or advice or opinions. Any kind of input would be nice to hear, this isn't something I feel comfortable talking about with anyone in my life.

Thank you!